college vs directionless abyss
An article in today’s Oregonian shares the news that Oregon high schools are “not preparing students for college and careers”
This report responds to concerns that the state will not meet “Oregon Progress Board's goal of seeing at least 20 percent of our youth graduate from high school, another 40 percent from community college and 40 percent more from a four-year college or university.”
I’ve been pondering on the topic of college and career preparation in high schools for a few weeks now.
We’ve seen many articles and studies demonstrating fewer men are attending college. Theories abound about how to attract men to the four-year college experience, yet there are very few suggestions as to where the men are going after high school.
I know a 22-year-old who just joined the US military. He did this not out of patriotic duty, but because in the four years since high school he has suffered from an absolute loss of direction. Now, as some of his high school classmates are preparing to graduate from college, he’s shipping out in hopes that the military can help develop his skills and show him options he doesn’t currently see.
My little sister is about to graduate from high school and hopes to go to college, yet her facebook profile proclaims a weekly dread of academia.
The question isn’t how well young people are prepared for college; the question is what do they do if they don’t go to college?
I attended college against great adversity. I am the only person in my immediate family to attend college, much less finish. My closest relative to also hold a bachelor’s degree is my dad’s cousin. I believe in the opportunity for every young person to be presented with the option to attend college – in fact provision of those opportunities has become my life’s work thus far – but there should be more than one option.
Perhaps my sister will follow my path and perhaps she won’t, but I promise we have both been fed the same statement with regard to success in life -- attending college is the only way to find success.
College worked for me. I enjoyed academia and flourished in the culture. It has helped bring me success. But, I can’t help think I got lucky. I’m not lucky to be successful (I worked hard for my success), but I am lucky the things I am good at happen to be the things society values.
So, let’s say the Oregon Progress Board achieves their goal of college attendance for 40% of the population by placing the premium of success on the college experience. What happens to the other 60%?
Will they simply wander directionless through life?
It seems the state of Oregon would be better served by taking a realistic approach and offering a suite of options including college, community college, trade and tech school, military service and certification programs.
High school students should be taught they have multiple options – not College vs. Directionless Abyss.

